Friday, April 27, 2018

Review: Thanos Annual


As we all know by this point, I adore Donny Cates's Thanos run, so I naturally sprung to get the Annual when I discovered we'd be getting a variety of stories from various writers familiar with the character, much like Action Comics #1000, except each story was focused on Thanos's cruelty rather than Superman's kindness. So, once more, I dove into the stories, gave individual takes, and ranked each one.


"Titan's Greatest Dad" 
Written by: Donny Cates 
Art by: Geoff Shaw, Antonio Fabela 

"Titan's Greatest Dad" is narrated by Cosmic Ghost Rider, the overall host of the annual, and focuses on the upbringing of Gamora, something that Cates's never really touched upon in his run. On top of very pretty art by Shaw, it's incredibly dark, with an excellent twist that showcases the depths of Thanos's cruelty and commitment to said cruelty. It's a strong start, if somewhat brief. 


"What To Get From The Man Who Has Everything" 
Written by: Christopher Hastings 
Art by: Flaviano, Fedrico Blee

Hasting's contribution to the anthology was an incredibly dark comedy focused on David, a young man who is tormented by Thanos on his birthday. Flaviano's art is cartoonish enough to sell the comedy, on top of pulling off an intimidating, if exaggerated, Thanos. I'm beginning to suspect all of these will be brief, but this one uses the lack of space most effectively to pull off some really great gags. 


"Exhibition"
Written by: Kieron Gillen
Art by: Andre Araujo, Chris O'Hallorahan 

Each of these stories feels like a different aspect of Thanos's villainy, and Exhibition is all about his unshakable love for Lady Death. Araujo's art is the real stand-out, capturing a lot of what I liked about classic Frank Quitely while also coming off as more colorful and larger in scale. Gillen's Thanos is every bit as cruel as Cates's, but comes off as more emotional, with a surprise appearance by the wicked Mephisto balancing him out. 


"My Little Hands" 
Written by: Katie Cook
Art by: Heather Breckle 

"Little Hands" reminded me a lot of I Hate Fairyland, largely because of the dissonance between the cutesy art and the incredibly brutal tone. It involves Thanos being trapped on a world of adorable puffballs that worship a heart at the center of the Earth, and takes a real drastic turn. This one is arguably the only story where Thanos isn't entirely at fault, making it all the funnier. Of course, the real stand-out is Breckle's art, which infuses the story with a Sunday paper comic strip feel a la Calvin and Hobbes. Short, but immensely sweet. 


"That Time Thanos Helped An Old Lady Cross the Street"
Written by: Ryan North
Art by: Will Robson and Rachelle Rosenberg 

For someone who ]traditionally portrays Thanos as a punching bag in his run on Squirrel Girl, Ryan North perfectly nails the more deceptive and tactical aspect of Thanos. The entire story is merely a polite and jovial Thanos helping a friendly old woman cross the street, but the reveal of his motives makes it one of the petty and evil things he's ever done. To quote North's Galactus, "What a tool."


"The Comfort of the Good" 
Written by: Al Ewing 
Art by: Frazier Irving

Probably the least comedic of the stories, "Comfort of the Good" is all about Thanos's cruelty and the effect it has on others. It's helped by Irving's art, which is expressive but also alien, truly feeling like an entirely hostile story to the readers. It also ends with a typical Ewing contemplation of the afterlife and how our behavior is sculpted by it, and how the mere presence of a rival god can throw your entire belief system into question. 

Ultimately, I really dug this annual, and I don't think there's a single weak story in the bunch. It's a strong ending to an excellent run, and it even ends with an exciting cliffhanger for the upcoming Cosmic Ghost Rider miniseries. If you've loved this run, or even just want some great Thanos stories, grab this. 

Ranking: 
*That Time Thanos Helped An Old Lady Cross the Street
*My Little Hands
*What To Get From The Man Who Has Everything
*Exhibition
*The Comfort of the Good
*Titan's Greatest Dad

Wednesday, April 25, 2018

Why Guardians of the Galaxy 2 Is Underrated


When Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 came out, it did very well financially, but got a sort of mixed response critically. They liked it, generally, but there was lots of complaint about how the film wasn't as fresh as it's predecessor and how it had too much going on visually. While I think there are merits to these arguments, I feel like it's led to the film being ignored in favor of Spider-Man: Homecoming and Thor: Ragnarok, both of which came out the same year to much more praise. In my mind, Guardians 2 is a bold, moving film, and a recent rewatch confirmed a lot of those feelings for me. 

The biggest factor for me, which was a general turn-off for audiences, was that it's truly James Gunn's films. Every line, every character beat, every scene feels exactly like what he wanted it to be, creating a sense of unity that a lot of the more "by committee" Marvel films tend to have. It feels personal in a way no MCU film ever really is, investing the audience in the characters more. 

In terms of emotional investment, I think this one's hard to top. Traditionally, MCU films always up the stakes, leaving little room for the characters to grow emotionally, but Guardians 2 focuses really heavily on the team as a whole. Sure, Peter's father issues comes first, but there's also Gamora's relationship with Nebula, Drax mourning his wife and child, and Rocket trying to drive everyone away. By the end of the film, these issues are dealt with in a satisfying fashion, and we're left feeling like the Guardians have truly become the family none of them ever got to have. Fittingly, it ends with the funeral of Yondu, who established himself as a surrogate father and lovable antihero just in time to die, leaving a solid chunk of the audience in tears as Cat Stevens plays us out. 

And I know/that I have to go away...

And the death of Yondu flies in the face of a frequent criticism of Marvel films: they don't take risks. By the end of this film, a major supporting character has given his life to save his adopted son, and it has real impact in a way the rest of the MCU didn't. This is on top of not one, but three, entertaining villains and a legitimately important lesson of "No matter how you are, there are always people who will love you." 

At the end of the day, Guardians 2 isn't the best MCU film, but it's arguably the bravest and most uncompromising we've seen from the franchise thus far, meaning it definitely deserves a second look from a lot of skeptics. 

Thursday, April 19, 2018

Review: Action Comics #1000


Anyone who knows me knows that I love Superman. He's pretty much my favorite DC character, and he's often a character that writers botch. So when DC decides to celebrate his 80th birthday by putting out a special 80-page 1000th issue of Action Comics, I knew I had to jump at the chance and buy it, just to see who would be telling the stories within. So, 2 hours later, here's my review (and ranking) of each story.m



"From The City That Has Everything" 
Writer: Dan Jurgens 
Artist: Norm Rampund 

#1000 starts with a story by the current writer of Action, Dan Jurgens, and it's probably the most standard fare of any of the books. The basic gist of the story is that the city of Metropolis decides to honor Superman by throwing an event where people can speak about what Superman means to them. Clark's reluctant to attend, but he does stay to witness all the people who's lives he's changed, Rampund's art does an effective job at drawing Clark and his family, with one really excellent splash panel at the end showcasing wider talent with a variety of characters, but the real stand-out is Jurgens. As the man whose been writing Superman for the better part of 30 years, he totally nails the voice of the character and what he means to a people as a whole, even if some dialogue is a bit clunky from time-to-time. 


"Neverending Battle" 
Writer: Peter Tomasi 
Artist: Patrick Gleason 

Of all the stories, this one easily feels the most like a love letter, so naturally it's written by the regular writer of the Superman comics, Peter Tomasi. This story involves Superman trapped by Vandal Savage and flung through time, so we get to see the various eras of Superman, from the Golden Age to the gritty future of Kingdom Come. Tomasi plays up Clark's inability to give up and uses the different eras to showcase how important that is to him as a trait, with Gleason's absolutely stunning art portraying the various eras. So far, two for two. 


"An Enemy Within" 
Writer: Marv Wolfman (Based off a story by Cindy Goff)
Artist: Curt Swan

The next story was an apparent remake or retelling of a Silver Age Superman story drawn by the late, great Curt Swan, whose famously regarded as the Silver Age Superman artist. It's fairly brief, focusing on a hostage situation in Metropolis which Superman is too busy to deal with. If every story is a celebration of a different part of Superman, "Enemy Within" is an ode to his faith in humanity to do what's right. That above all steers Superman's role as a hero, and to see it play out in a fairly brief story was touching. 


"The Game" 
Writers: Neal Adams, Paul Levitz
Artist: Paul Levitz

"The Game" is a story about a game of chess between Superman and Lex Luthor, and while Adams and Levitz do a good job with their voices, it feels fairly rushed. In a matter of panels, the game is over and Luthor springs a largely ineffective trap, then the story is over. While it's a strong showcase of the characters, I feel like this one would've worked better if it was longer, and perhaps drawn by a slightly less messy artist. 


"The Car" 
Writer: Geoff Johns and Richard Donner
Artist: Oliver Coipel

"The Car" is all about the driver of the car that Superman destroyed in the iconic cover of his first appearance in Action Comics, and like most things written by Geoff Johns, it's not very subtle, but it's still got that perfect Christopher Reeves-era voice that Johns (with the help of Superman I/II director  Richard Donner) tends to give him. Coipel's art evokes the Golden Age without ever straight-up aping it, coming off as extra expressive and easy to follow. This story plays into the Siegel/Shiuster era of Superman's faith in all men and more rebellious stances. Golden Age Superman was a champion of the downtrodden, and his conversation with Butch, the driver of the car, hints towards that. 


"The Fifth Season"
Writer: Scott Snyder
Artist: Rafael Albuquerque

Between this and "The Game", this one was easily the stronger Superman/Lex Luthor story. Dealing with Superman tracking down Lex Luthor to the Smallville Planetarium, it reads most like a bittersweet take on their rivalry. These men were friends once, and to some degree, that affection is still there. Albuquerque's art doesn't always nail the expressions of the character, but there's still some very pretty moments throughout the comic, especially whenever the characters witness their local planetarium. It's about the same length of "The Game", but it tells so much more. 


"Of Tomorrow" 
Writer: Tom King
Artist: Clay Mann

"Of Tomorrow" is clearly a Tom King story, because it's easily the saddest, but it's also a showcase of King's strength of applying deeply personal themes to larger-than-life characters. In this case, it's dealing with the death of your parents, and how to move on from that. Of course, the Kents have been dead for centuries at the point of this story, but it's clear that Superman still loves and cherishes them from the fact that he still visits their grave every year. In a lot of ways, the Kents are one of the most important parts of Superman's backstory, giving him the ideals he lives by and fights for, and it's a sweet send-off to characters that many writers tend to ignore. 


"Five Minutes" 
Writer: Louise Simonson
Artist: Jerry Ordway 

"Five Minutes" is written by Louise Simonson with art by Ordway, whose up there with Jurgens or Johns as an iconic writer of the character, and it details Superman stopping a series of accidents with five minutes until he has a deadline on story. As the era of Superman I'm mostly familiar with, it was a blast of nostalgia to see Clark interacting with characters like Perry White or Bibbo Bibbowski. Of all the stories, this one benefits the most from a lack of length, and I almost expected it to end with the classic "wink at the camera" many Superman stories like this do. 


"Actionland" 
Writer: Paul Dini
Artist: Jose-Luis Garcia Lopez

"Actionland" has all the trademarks of a Paul Dini story: fun visuals, beautifully drawn people (thanks Lopez), and a total encapsulation of Superman's history, rogues, and the role he plays in his villians's lives. As a story about the apparent final battle of Superman and reality-warper Mr. Mxyzptlk, a villain whose a particular favorite of Dini's, it's sweet, simple, and like all of Dini's contributions to DC: fun. 


"Faster Than A Speeding Bullet"
Writer: Brad Meltzer
Artist: John Cassady 

"Speeding Bullet" is a Superman ending a hostage crisis in a matter of seconds, and while there's a few good moments in it, it felt a bit like a retread, while Cassady's art felt somewhat stiff. Which is a shame, because I adore his work on things like Planetary, where he was given a chance to flex some creative muscles. Here? It's mostly just Superman. 


"The Truth" 
Writer: Brian Micheal Bendis 
Artist: Jim Lee

Of all the stories in this collection, it's this one that's probably the most important, as Brian Micheal Bendis will be taking over as the writer of Superman. You can tell DC wanted this to be a big deal, because a) it's at the very end and b) is drawn by superstar Jim Lee, who does good, if not super compelling, work here. Ultimately, this story struggled because it feels like a regular Superman comic got pushed into the middle of this celebration of the character. Bendis doesn't play Superman as quippy. but ultimately I'm worried that his run will be playing to Bendis's weaknesses, namely his love of bombastic, cosmic-level threats to established characters. 

As a fan of Alias and Daredevil, I can tell you that Bendis works best when he's telling deeply personal stories about established villains like the Kingpin or the Purple Man, while his more traditional works often shoehorn in boring villains to fit the larger scales of the stories. Rogol Zaar, the new villain, has an interesting design but unclear motives. Maybe I'll be wrong, but Bendis's track record suggests that his run may be off to a bumpy start. 

Conclusion
Ultimately, #1000 is a solid variety of stories all about the various elements of what make Superman such an icon, and even though it dips from time-to-time and lacks well-known voices like Grant Morrison, it's still a really good read for any fans of the character.

Rankings
Neverending Battle
The Fifth Season
The Car
Five Minutes
Of Tomorrow
Actionland
An Enemy Within
From the City That Has Everything
The Game
Faster Than A Speeding Bullet
The Truth

Tuesday, April 17, 2018

Review: "A Quiet Place" Is A Solid Horror Debut





A Quiet Place is the third film from John Krasinski, and easily his most ambitious. A sci-fi horror film largely devoid of dialogue and reliant on natural sounds and tension, it had every chance to fail, but instead lands as a mostly solid horror flick with a strong emphasis on family and survival.

The film's cast is largely minimal, consisting of only four major characters: Lee (John Krasinski), Evelyn (Emily Blunt), Marcus (Christopher Jupe), and Regan (Millicent Simmonds). As such, the film would likely fail if any one of these performances was weak, making it a nice surprise that each member of the cast is fairly strong.

Krasinski and Blunt, as a real-life couple, have a natural chemistry, really selling themselves as both a couple and as parents. Krasinki carries himself with a gruff exterior, with his usage of ASL coming off as to the point, while Blunt is much loving and affectionate in her delivery. Simmonds handles a role that could've been irritating with aplomb, selling adolescent frustration and guilt with a sensitivity. Jupe is probably the weakest link, but it's largely because his character is rarely anything other than frightened in his scenes. Of the four, Krasinski is easily the strongest, using the lack of dialogue to convey so much emotion through body language and facial expressions. Desperate, angry, joyful, he pulls it all off without really trying.
The film handles it's setting, a world ravaged following an invasion by creatures that prey on sound, fairly well, focusing largely on allowing the audience to learn details through things like newspaper clippings or writing in notebooks. The film is fairly tightly-plotted, with set-up elements paying off throughout the film and building towards a satisfying climax, but it struggles like many horror films do with characters making dumb decisions. The biggest victim of this is Lee, the supposedly grizzled survivor, who, in the film's third act, makes a series of inexplicably dumb decisions in rapid succession with no real explanation as to why beyond that the plot needed to progress in this fashion.
Where the film truly surprises is selling the relationships between the various family members. These characters feel like a real family, and you want them to survive this tense situation. Several interactions carried real emotional weight, and I actually found myself with a lump in my throat at a few points.
The film never really pushes the limit in terms of shot designs or framing, but it never feels overly chaotic either. There are several moments where I wished Krasinski had pushed the envelope more, largely in terms of the film's reliance on jump scares in the first half over the long sequences of creeping tension where it really excelled. The scares felt especially forced, especially since the film used silence so well that pretty much any noise came as a jolt.
Another point of annoyance was the lack of originality behind the monster's designs. The monsters looked like a larger, slimier mix of the Demigorgon from Stranger Things and the monster from Cloverfield (which plays into the possible Cloverfield connection that was nearly forced on us). This was more of a personal gripe, but in an era where directors like Guillermo Del Toro can create visually stunning monsters for the same amount of money, it's something of a letdown.
Ultimately, A Quiet Place has it's flaws, but it's short runtime and excellent cast really prevent the film from ever overstaying it's welcome. It's inventive, scary, and leaves you with just enough questions that you'll find yourself thinking about long after the credits have rolled.

Thursday, April 12, 2018

"Thanos Wins" Comes to A Satisfying Conclusion


A couple weeks back, I wrote about Donny Cates and Geoff Shaw's run on Thanos, which is probably the best book of their respective careers and the strongest Marvel Cosmic book since the end of Abnett and Lanning's run on Guardians of the Galaxy. So I had fairly lofty expectations going into the final issue of the "Thanos Wins" story. And, naturally, they were met exceptionally well. 

#18 of Thanos's run opens with the two Thanos's victorious, having slain their foe, and now are apparently the last two beings in the entire universe. With their beloved Lady Death standing before them, the duo come to the realization that in order for them to be with Death, one of them must die. 


What ensues is a nearly issue-long fight scene, with almost no dialogue save for the opening narration, between the two Thanos's (Thanii? Thaneese?) as they engage in one final, knock-down, drag-out fight. Unlike the numerous other fights throughout the run, this one lacks the over-the-top visuals, which should've crippled it, but Shaw gives the fight an intensely personal feel. Every blow feels so visceral, it's hard not to wince at some of the more brutal hits. The entire fight feels resigned, destined to happen whether the two wanted it or not. 

These spills out into the narration as well, as Cates brings Thanos's arc full-circle. A frequent criticism of the series was that it lacked the character development most takes on the character had given him, but this issue makes it clear that the comic is all about Thanos's personal struggle, not just with the universe as a whole, but with himself. The final fight takes it to the literal extreme, but it ends on a poignant note for the character, who admits a seething self-hatred for himself that will hopefully be picked up on in Infinity Countdown, a Marvel Cosmic event that Cates ends the issue urging people to read if they want more of the Mad Titan.

Thanos was fairly brief, but it's such promising work from both Cates and Shaw they they've quickly become creators I'll read anything from. It's funny, creative, tragic, and most of all, fun. With one more Annual, where the Cosmic Ghost Rider narrates some of Thanos's most notable adventures, to go, there should be no reason why you aren't reading this. In fact, there's no reason why you haven't pre-ordered the upcoming Cosmic Ghost Rider book too, while you're at it. 

Wednesday, April 11, 2018

Who (Or What) Is the Upcoming Threat In Legion?


Legion's second episode certainly put a lot of my uncertainty about the first to rest, but it also raised a few more questions. Namely, who (or what) is coming that could be such a threat that David needs to actively assist the parasite that's been dead-set on ruining his life? 

For those who don't quite understand the question, please watch the show, because there's going to be some spoilers and it's also very good. 

Basically, we discovered at the end of last week's season premiere that the mysterious orb that took David was built by Syd and, if a musing by Cary in this week is anything to go by, Cary in some not-too-distant future. In the orb, Syd wordlessly explained to David that he needs to help the Shadow King locate his body before dropping him in a nightclub in France. This week, David is able to communicate with Future-Syd in a proper conversation, and she warns that David will kill the Shadow King a week from now (whether that means next episode or further down the line remains to be seen) and it will leave a power vacuum filled by some "thing" that in turn kills David, alongside most of the planet. When David tries to get more answers, Future-Syd severs their communication, leaving him uncertain and eager to seek out the Shadow King for answers. 

As for the greater threat, I'm certain we'll get to the answer of that before the end of this season, but for now I've got a prediction: En Sabah Nur, better known as Apocalypse. 


For those unfamiliar with Apocalypse, he's the first ever mutant in the main timeline of Earth-616 and a frequent foe of the X-Men. Apocalypse is a figure that inspires massive cults of worship wherever he goes, and he's likely the most powerful enemy the X-Men have done battle with. In one particular case, his unchecked rise to power led to the Age of Apocalypse event, which was brought about by David accidentally killing a younger version of his father before he could form the X-Men, leading to a dystopia in which Apocalypse has wiped out most of the human race. 

When the idea of the threat being Apocalypse first came into my mind, it initially stemmed from Syd mentioning that it killed most of the world, David included. Outside of the Pheonix Force (which is likely off limits due to the upcoming Dark Pheonix movie), I can't imagine any other unchecked threat that the show could be playing towards, especially given how heavily the show is tying into the concept of delusions and planting ideas through Jon Hamm's mysterious Narrator. 

A major part of Apocalypse's story is that he believes himself to be a god and mutantkind's greatest hope, regardless of whether his behavior matches his motifs. In fact, a major element of Rick Remender's Uncanny X-Force run was whether or not a young reincarnation of Apocalypse could be taught to be benevolent and kind. So, perhaps Hamm's Narrator is actually a major player in the series, his speeches (coupled with the scene of a Shadow King-possessed Oliver teaching a young child false information) foreshadowing the rise of a mutant tyrant who can't be stopped unless someone like the Shadow King is there to stop him. 

It's hard to predict or entirely be sure at this point, but after the utter letdown that was the portrayal of Apocalypse in 2016's X-Men: Apocalypse, perhaps a take from Noah Hawley, a man famed for writing compelling villains, could give the character the mainstream portrayal he deserves. 

Wednesday, April 4, 2018

"Legion" is Back, But Is It Just a Fluke?


So, Legion came back, and it was unsurprisingly great, but there was moments where my least favorite aspect of the show's first season reared it's head. That issue, at least for me, was the show's occasional tendency to be weird with no real explanation or payoff and hope that it was visually interesting enough for you not to wonder what the heck that previous stuff was about. It's fun to witness, but often lacks focus and distracts from the real story. My problem with it stems largely from the fear that the show may become more reliant on it's visuals and go the way of, say, Heroes, which climbed thoroughly up it's ass after the first season. 

One of the two biggest perpetrators of this in the first episode was Admiral Fukuyama, the shadowy head of Division 3, who wears a giant basket on his head and communicates through mustachioed women with Alexa voices.

I'm not joking.

It's certainly fascinating to look at and gives scenes with him a weird tension, but is it necessary? Could he have just been a dude in a suit? I'm not one to question Noah Hawley, but I'm also just spitballing here. 

The other major weird bit was the narrator played by Jon Hamm. I love Jon Hamm in everything, to the point that I'll ignore the fact that he might also be playing Mr. Sinister at some point in the future, making this yet another weird plothole within the increasingly tangled and confusing X-Men timeline. 

Crumple this entire timeline up and throw into the sun. 

Throughout the first episode, monologues by Hamm are sprinkled. These speeches cover philosophy and the origin of delusions in comparison to regular ideas, and while the segments they're placed over are very disturbing and fun to watch, they feel somewhat vague. Sure, the delusions speech directly plays into the battle with the Shadow King and sets up the excellent reveal at the end of the episode, but what was the greater point of Chinese thinker Zhuanghazi, beyond perhaps setting up the idea that David is still trapped in the orb or even still stuck at Clockwork Asylum? 

Legion's a good show, arguably the best one Marvel has ever produced, so these are more worries than they are actual criticisms. But, ultimately, these worries stem from fear that Legion is going to end up like True Detective, a show that started brilliantly and went off the rails in it's second season by deciding to go as pretentious as possible. As long as Hawley continues to plot smartly and the cast continues to be excellent, I suspect things will be fine. But hey, just remember that this could go down at any point. 

Tuesday, April 3, 2018

Review: Pacific Rim: Uprising is Loud, Dumb Fun


The original Pacific Rim holds a special place in my heart. Directed by genius and long-overdue Oscar winner Guillermo Del Toro, it's gorgeous, thrilling, and singlehandedly dragged me out of a depressed funk by being exactly what I needed at that time. So, when it became clear Guillermo wasn't directing this one, I naturally got worried, and when the trailers made it look less impressive than the original, I got a bit more worried. Could former Daredevil showrunner Steven S. DeKnight tarnish my affection for the original by turning in a shoddy sequel? Hell, they could've even get Charlie Hunnam to reprise his role as Raliegh, clearly this will be a disaster! 

As it turns out, I really shouldn't stress out about these kind of things. 

Ten years after the end of the first film, the world is still rebuilding following mankind's apparent victory of the Kaiju. Societies have been built around the corpses of the giant beasts, with notable black markets still profiting, and the military defenders of Earth find themselves debating between continuing with human Jaeger pilots or allowing the mysterious Shao Corporation to privatize the industry and replace them with fully automated drones. Jake Pentecost (John Boyega), son of Idris Elba's Stacker, is forcibly drafted into the program to escape jail time, and alongside rival pilot Nate Lambert (Scott Eastwood, who is clearly filling the role Raleigh would've played had Hunnam come back), must train a new team of pilots from all around the world in order to challenge the mysterious "rogue Jaeger" that threatens to tear the whole program down and bring back the Kaiju. If they don't succeed, the entire world could be at stake. 

The first thing you need to get about Uprising is that it's not a thinking man's film. It's simplistic, oftentimes cliched, and clips along at a fairly quick pace. But it makes up for with a mix of sheer spectacle and solid performances across the board. Boyega, in particular, is excellent, playing Jake as a lovable, swaggering hotshot with a fragile side. In comparison to Raleigh, he's a much more compelling and interesting character to follow. Eastwood is...fine as Lambert, playing the usual stoic, hardass he plays in film like this. The recruits are all largely two-dimensional, never being much beyond recognizable archetypes (snarky Brit, stoic Russian, slapstick Indian, etc.) with the exception of Amara Namani (Cailee Spaeny), an orphan that provides the film with it's central heart through her friendship with Jake. Spaeny and Boyega have a natural chemistry and bounce off each other in the scenes they share, making their storyline click especially well. 

In terms of returning cast, Charlie Day and Burn Gorman are both great as Drs. Newton Geiszler and Herman Gottlieb, fitting back into the characters but adding some development onto them. Day, specifically, is even more fun in this one. Rinko Kukichi is good as Mako, if largely underused and relegated to a supporting role. It would've been nice to see her take part in one of the film's big battles. 

In terms of the films visuals and style, DeKnight lacks Del Toro's sense of scale, with the Jaegers and Kaiju never quite feeling real in the same way they did in the first one. For instance, there's never a moment as breathtaking as Gipsy Danger stumbling onto the beach in the original, while the fact that the film is shot in broad daylight gives everything a plastic feeling. However, what he lacks in scale he makes up for with fluidity, with the film's numerous fight scenes feeling perfectly put together. Never do you feel lost in the same way one would during a Transformers film, with the fights between Gipsy Avenger and the rogue Jaeger being particularly fun. Ironically, the Jaeger v Jaeger fights are more interesting than the clashes with the Kaiju. 

The plot, naturally, is fairly standard fare, outside of a villain twist that will probably prove divisive. (My friend group was split pretty much 50/50 on it, with defenders enjoying the role while detractors found it nonsensical and somewhat pandering.) There's laughs, emotional moments, and a fair amount of technobabble, but it all clicks so well you don't really mind. 

Ultimately, is Uprising a great movie? Probably not. Is it a fun way to spend two hours and a worthy sequel to the original? Absolutely.